Insurance Company Reviews

Honest, in-depth reviews of the top insurance companies in America. Compare rates, coverage options, and customer satisfaction to find the right insurer for you.

State Farm

Est. 1922
A++
Customer Rating
4.2
Claims Rating
4.1
50 states16.2% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

GEICO

Est. 1936
A++
Customer Rating
4.0
Claims Rating
4.0
50 states14.1% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Progressive

Est. 1937
A+
Customer Rating
3.8
Claims Rating
3.9
50 states13.8% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Allstate

Est. 1931
A+
Customer Rating
3.9
Claims Rating
3.8
50 states9.6% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

USAA

Est. 1922
A++
Customer Rating
4.8
Claims Rating
4.7
50 states5.8% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Liberty Mutual

Est. 1912
A
Customer Rating
3.7
Claims Rating
3.8
50 states5.2% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Nationwide

Est. 1926
A+
Customer Rating
3.9
Claims Rating
4.0
47 states4.2% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Farmers

Est. 1928
A
Customer Rating
3.8
Claims Rating
3.7
48 states3.8% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Travelers

Est. 1864
A++
Customer Rating
4.0
Claims Rating
4.1
50 states3.4% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

American Family

Est. 1927
A
Customer Rating
4.1
Claims Rating
4.0
19 states2.4% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Erie

Est. 1925
A+
Customer Rating
4.5
Claims Rating
4.4
12 states1.8% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Auto-Owners

Est. 1916
A++
Customer Rating
4.3
Claims Rating
4.2
26 states1.6% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Safeco

Est. 1923
A
Customer Rating
3.9
Claims Rating
4.0
50 states1.4% market share
AutoHome
Read Full Review →

The Hartford

Est. 1810
A+
Customer Rating
4.2
Claims Rating
4.1
50 states1.2% market share
AutoHome
Read Full Review →

AAA/CSAA

Est. 1900
A+
Customer Rating
4.1
Claims Rating
4.0
23 states1.1% market share
AutoHomeLife
Read Full Review →

Compare Companies Side-by-Side

Not sure which company is right for you? Check out our popular comparisons.

Ready to Compare Quotes?

Get free quotes from verified agents and see real prices from these companies.

Get Free Quotes