Insurance Comparison

State Farm vs Safeco

State Farm and Safeco offer different distribution models. State Farm has dedicated agents nationwide, while Safeco (owned by Liberty Mutual) sells through independent agents primarily in certain regions.

Our Pick: State Farm
RECOMMENDED

State Farm

4.2
AM Best RatingA++
Avg. Auto Rate$1,674/yr
Market Share16.2%
States Available50
Claims Rating4.1/5

Safeco

3.9
AM Best RatingA
Avg. Auto Rate$1,512/yr
Market Share1.4%
States Available50
Claims Rating4.0/5

Winner by Category

State Farm
Category
Safeco
Tie
Price
Tie
Tie
Coverage Options
Tie
Winner
Customer Service
Tie
Claims Handling
Tie
Winner
Discounts
Winner
Overall Winner

Price Comparison

Prices are generally competitive between the two. State Farm may offer better bundling discounts, while Safeco rates vary more by independent agent.

Coverage Options

Both offer comprehensive coverage. Safeco has RightTrack telematics. State Farm has Drive Safe & Save.

Customer Service

State Farm has the largest dedicated agent network. Safeco works through independent agents who may offer multiple company options.

Which Company Is Right for You?

Choose State Farm If You:

  • Want dedicated agent relationship
  • Need largest agent network
  • Prefer comprehensive bundling
  • Value brand recognition

Choose Safeco If You:

  • Prefer independent agents
  • Want to compare multiple insurers
  • Like RightTrack telematics
  • Live in strong Safeco markets

Frequently Asked Questions

Is State Farm or Safeco cheaper?

Prices are competitive and vary by location. Get quotes from both to compare.

Who owns Safeco?

Safeco is owned by Liberty Mutual but operates as a separate brand through independent agents.

Which has more agents?

State Farm has far more dedicated agents. Safeco is available through independent agents who also sell other companies.

Compare State Farm & Safeco Quotes

Get personalized quotes from both companies and more. Find the best rate for your specific situation.

Get Free Quotes