Farmers vs State Farm
Farmers and State Farm are both agent-based insurers offering comprehensive coverage. State Farm is larger and typically cheaper, while Farmers offers strong coverage in Western states.
Farmers
State Farm
Winner by Category
Price Comparison
State Farm is typically 10-15% cheaper than Farmers. Farmers' New Car Pledge can provide value for new car owners.
Coverage Options
Both offer comprehensive coverage options. Farmers' New Car Pledge extends new car replacement to 2 years/24,000 miles versus State Farm's standard coverage.
Customer Service
Both have strong agent networks. State Farm has more agents overall, while Farmers has strong presence in Western states.
Which Company Is Right for You?
Choose Farmers If You:
- Live in Western states (strong Farmers presence)
- Own a new car (New Car Pledge)
- Prefer Farmers' Signal telematics
- Want 2-year new car replacement
Choose State Farm If You:
- Looking for lower rates
- Want largest agent network
- Need comprehensive bundling
- Prefer most established insurer
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Farmers or State Farm cheaper?
State Farm is typically cheaper by 10-15%. Farmers may be competitive in specific areas, particularly Western states.
What is Farmers New Car Pledge?
If you total your new car within 2 years or 24,000 miles, Farmers replaces it with the same make and model. This is longer than most competitors offer.
Which is better in California?
Both are strong in California. Farmers has deep roots in Western states while State Farm has more agents statewide.
Compare Farmers & State Farm Quotes
Get personalized quotes from both companies and more. Find the best rate for your specific situation.
Get Free Quotes