Allstate vs Progressive
Allstate and Progressive offer different value propositions. Allstate emphasizes local agents and comprehensive coverage, while Progressive focuses on competitive pricing and flexibility.
Allstate
Progressive
Winner by Category
Price Comparison
Progressive is typically 15-20% cheaper than Allstate. Both offer telematics programs that can provide additional savings.
Coverage Options
Allstate offers more comprehensive coverage options, especially for bundling. Progressive is more flexible for high-risk drivers.
Customer Service
Allstate has strong local agent network, while Progressive focuses on digital convenience. Allstate is better for personalized service.
Which Company Is Right for You?
Choose Allstate If You:
- Want local agent support
- Need comprehensive bundling
- Low-mileage driver (Milewise)
- Prefer established brand
Choose Progressive If You:
- Looking for lower rates
- High-risk driver needing coverage
- Want Snapshot telematics savings
- Prefer digital self-service
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Allstate or Progressive cheaper?
Progressive is typically cheaper by 15-20%. Both offer telematics programs for additional savings.
Which is better for high-risk drivers?
Progressive is more likely to offer coverage to high-risk drivers at reasonable rates.
Which has better bundling?
Allstate is better for bundling as they write their own policies. Progressive partners with other companies.
Compare Allstate & Progressive Quotes
Get personalized quotes from both companies and more. Find the best rate for your specific situation.
Get Free Quotes