Liberty Mutual vs Progressive
Liberty Mutual and Progressive are both major national insurers. Liberty Mutual offers unique features like new car replacement, while Progressive focuses on competitive pricing and flexibility.
Liberty Mutual
Progressive
Winner by Category
Price Comparison
Progressive is typically 15-20% cheaper than Liberty Mutual. However, Liberty Mutual's comprehensive coverage features may justify the higher price for some drivers.
Coverage Options
Liberty Mutual offers unique features like new car replacement and lifetime repair guarantee. Progressive has standard coverage with more pricing flexibility.
Customer Service
Both offer primarily digital service with some agent support. Liberty Mutual's claims process is highly rated with their lifetime repair guarantee.
Which Company Is Right for You?
Choose Liberty Mutual If You:
- Own a new car (new car replacement)
- Want lifetime repair guarantee
- Prefer comprehensive coverage features
- Value claims handling quality
Choose Progressive If You:
- Looking for lowest price
- High-risk driver needing coverage
- Want telematics for maximum savings
- Prefer comparison shopping tools
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Liberty Mutual or Progressive cheaper?
Progressive is typically cheaper by 15-20%. Liberty Mutual's higher rates come with more comprehensive coverage features that may be worth it for some drivers.
What is Liberty Mutual's new car replacement?
If you total a new car within the first year, Liberty Mutual replaces it with a brand new car rather than paying depreciated value. Progressive doesn't offer this.
Which is better for high-risk drivers?
Progressive is more likely to offer coverage to high-risk drivers at reasonable rates. Liberty Mutual may decline or charge very high premiums for risky profiles.
Compare Liberty Mutual & Progressive Quotes
Get personalized quotes from both companies and more. Find the best rate for your specific situation.
Get Free Quotes